• 1.61K Posts
  • 3.12K Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: November 3rd, 2023

help-circle











  • Zilbagias

    I have been keeping up with the manga chapters that get posted to Mangadex and I feel similarly. It’s such a weird setup that I can’t say it is all working, but I am willing to keep reading to see where it goes. One thing I have been a bit disappointed by as the chapters have gone on (you are likely ahead of me), is that the whole idea of “taboo” seems to be so open-ended that it is not really clear what is or isn’t considered taboo. Like, as long as there can be some flimsy rationalization, then it can count. I don’t know if this gets better or not, but I thought that aspect was really interesting and has so far been under or poorly utilized.








  • wjs018@ani.socialMtoAnime@ani.socialRule Clarification
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    20 hours ago

    the sidebar rules specifically mention allowing “donghua”

    Getting into what is or isn’t anime can be thorny sometimes. The rule of thumb I follow, which I have mentioned in the past, is that if a show/movie has either a MAL or AniList page, then it is relevant enough for this community. AniList includes donghua in their database, including this show, so it is fine to post about.

    What this discussion has made me realize though, is that the bot wasn’t tracking donghua like it does anime. The AniList api includes it, but I was filtering to just the JP shows. So, I will be removing that filter going forward. I apologize retroactively to all the donghua fans out there that didn’t have a place to talk about it.


  • wjs018@ani.socialMtoAnime@ani.socialRule Clarification
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    20 hours ago

    This discussion has also made me realize that, despite them being listed on AniList, the bot wasn’t tracking any shows marked as Chinese origin on AniList. I will rectify this going forward. I have stated before that any show with an AniList or MAL page is fair game for this community, and I will make sure that the bot follows those rules to the best of my ability.

    Thanks for helping me find this little hiccup with the bot!


  • wjs018@ani.socialMtoAnime@ani.socialRule Clarification
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    edit-2
    20 hours ago

    Alright, popping back in here after a busy day and wanted to thank everybody for their input. I will do some thinking on it.

    In the meantime, considering the feedback here, I will not be adding rules against posting full-length, legally accessible episodes to this community. As I see it, there are a couple different acceptable reasons to post these:

    1. Posting episodes to discuss them when they have recently aired

    This would essentially be in place of a normal discussion thread created by the bot. The bot doesn’t let users request episode discussion threads that aired more than 30 days prior, so a similar rule should apply to full episodes posted to discuss that episode. Note that if you do this, let me know so that I can make sure these threads get included in the wiki of episode discussion threads.

    1. Posting an episode of an older (> 30 days) series that has finished airing in order to foster discussion of the series/genre/staff/visuals/etc.

    This would be similar to a recommendation thread (or a Watch This! thread from the subreddit). The basic rule here is that in addition to simply posting the link, a user would need to include some other content to contextualize or explain why they are posting the episode. This could be either in the post body or as a top level comment.

    1. Posting an episode as part of an organized rewatch.

    I have on my to-do list over the year-end holiday season to write up rules and guidance on organizing rewatches. If you want an already written guide, here is the subreddit wiki’s page on them. Basically, it would be a user-led effort to gather a group of interested parties to all watch through a series together. If a series that was being rewatched had full, legally accessible episodes, then those could serve as the rewatch threads.


    So, with this set of guidelines @sabreW4K3@lazysoci.al, I welcome you to resubmit the episode you posted. I just ask two things:

    1. That you make the title more informative/relevant rather than the autogenerated wall of kanji that most people in this community can’t read.
    2. That you also write up a bit about the show and why you are posting it to line up with the #2 point above. It doesn’t need to be long, but just something more than simply the link so that people know what they are watching and why you wanted to share it.

    Hopefully this can serve as a middle ground that allows posting of full-length episodes that are legally accessible as well as fostering discussion and community involvement.


  • wjs018@ani.socialMtoAnime@ani.socialRule Clarification
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    1 day ago

    I understand that I didn’t explicitly have any kind of rule against posting links to publicly, legally available full episodes, so I will be clarifying that going forward soon when I get a chance (on mobile atm).

    This community is really intended to be geared towards discussion/clips/news than sharing full-length episodes like that. Additionally, the episode was originally released almost two months ago, so it isn’t particularly timely (unless there is some wonky release stuff I am not aware of). However, I admit that this kind of thing was merely an intention on my behalf rather than something that all of us in the fediverse huddled together and decided collectively. So, I am open to feedback (such as this thread) on this kind of thing. In general, when I haven’t made rules about something, I tend to default back to what would have been allowed in the anime subreddit because they have had years of history to work through all the edge cases that can arise from rules.

    I would be more open to posts of full episodes that are legally available if it was part of some kind of community effort. Say, for example, that OP wanted to organize a group to watch this series together and discuss it (like a rewatch in the subreddit). Then, there could be some kind of schedule and an episode post would get made each day/week/whatever and the discussion among members of this community could happen in that post.


  • wjs018@ani.socialMtoAnime@ani.socialRule Clarification
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    17
    ·
    1 day ago

    For context for others, OP posted a link to Slay the Gods Episode 1 which is a Chinese ONA series. In that post I removed, I replied before removal:

    This seems like it is a full episode of a series. It isn’t really suited for this community which is more focused on news/clips/discussion. I am going to remove it, but if you want to create a discussion thread about the series you are welcome to do so.

    This might be more suited to a community dedicated to the series (I don’t know if it exists in the fediverse or not).

    This is the first instance of this happening, so I will be updating the rules about this going forward.